One of the most reliably contentious areas of a residential property sale, and one of the most straightforwardly avoidable sources of dispute, is the question of what the seller is leaving and what they are taking. Buyers arrive at completion expecting to find the home in the condition they viewed it. Sellers arrive at moving day with a van and items they have always assumed were theirs to take. When those two sets of assumptions do not match, the result is a dispute at the most stressful point in the transaction.
The good news is that the framework for resolving this exists, it is used in almost every residential sale, and getting it right requires nothing more than careful attention at an early stage.
The legal distinction: fixtures versus fittings
The law distinguishes between fixtures and fittings, and the distinction matters because fixtures are considered part of the property and transfer with it on sale, while fittings are the seller’s personal property and can be taken.
A fixture, in legal terms, is something that has been permanently attached to the structure of the property. The test applied by courts involves two questions: how securely is the item attached, and what was the purpose of attaching it? An item that is bolted to the floor or fixed to the wall, and whose purpose was to become part of the building, is a fixture. An item that rests on a surface or can be removed without damage to the structure, and whose attachment was for the item’s own enjoyment rather than the property’s improvement, is a fitting.
In practice, the distinction can be less obvious than it sounds. A fitted kitchen is a fixture. A freestanding range cooker is a fitting. A built-in wardrobe is a fixture. A wardrobe that sits against a wall and is fixed with a few screws sits in genuinely disputed territory, and disputes about exactly this kind of item are common. Garden sheds, greenhouse structures, and external installations such as satellite dishes occupy similarly uncertain ground.
The TA10: the form that resolves it
In conveyancing practice, the question of what is included in a sale and what is not is addressed through the Fittings and Contents Form, known as the TA10. This is a standard form completed by the seller as part of the conveyancing process and disclosed to the buyer through their solicitor. It covers a comprehensive list of items room by room and asks the seller to state for each whether it is included in the sale, excluded from the sale, or not present in the property.
The TA10 covers items including carpets and floor coverings, curtains and blinds, curtain rails and poles, light fittings, bathroom fittings, kitchen appliances, fitted units, garden items including sheds and plants, and a range of other standard categories. For each, the seller makes a clear declaration. Once agreed by both parties, the TA10 forms part of the contract.
Completing the TA10 carefully and honestly
The most important thing to understand about the TA10 is that it needs to be completed accurately and early in the process, not as an afterthought at the point of exchange. Buyers make decisions based on what they expect to be included. If a buyer views a property and sees integrated appliances, curtains, and a garden shed, they reasonably assume those things will be there when they move in, unless told otherwise in the TA10.
If items are excluded, the TA10 should say so clearly, and the buyer should be made aware of this before they make an offer. Disagreements that arise because a seller listed something as excluded on the TA10 but the buyer never read it carefully enough are frustrating for everyone. Disagreements that arise because excluded items were not disclosed until exchange are considerably more damaging.
Items that most commonly cause problems
Light fittings are one of the most frequent sources of dispute. Ceiling roses and wiring are fixtures; light fittings themselves are often treated as fittings that sellers want to take, particularly if they are designer pieces. The answer is to state clearly on the TA10 what is staying and, where a fitting is being taken, to replace it with something functional before completion so the buyer is not left with bare wires.
Curtains and blinds that were made to fit specific windows may have little value to the seller in a new property. Including them often costs the seller nothing and removes a potential area of dispute. Curtain poles and rails, which require wall fixings to remove, are more straightforwardly fixtures and buyers generally expect them to remain.
Garden items including sheds, greenhouses, established planters, and garden ornaments all need to be considered. A shed that has been bolted to a concrete base is a different matter from a lightweight plastic structure.
The practical approach
Walk through the property before instructing your solicitor and make a clear decision about everything you intend to take. Complete the TA10 carefully and completely. Raise anything unusual with your solicitor so it can be addressed in the contract. And if a buyer has specifically asked about an item during viewings, make sure the position is confirmed in writing rather than left to assumption.
Talk to our team about selling your home