Making an offer: How to pitch it, present yourself and negotiate well

Making an offer: How to pitch it, present yourself and negotiate well

The moment between finding a property you want and having an offer accepted is one of the most uncertain in the whole buying process. The asking price is a starting point set by the seller and their agent, not a fixed contract. Whether your offer is accepted, declined, or countered depends on a combination of the number itself, how you present your position, and what the seller’s priorities actually are. Understanding how to approach all three gives a buyer a meaningful advantage.

Research the price before you make a number

An offer made without reference to what the property is actually worth in the current market is a guess. Comparable evidence is what grounds it in something defensible. Before making an offer, look at what similar properties in the same road or immediate area have actually sold for, not what they were listed at. Sold prices are available through HM Land Registry and are visible on the major property portals. A property that sold six months ago for a certain figure gives you a benchmark that an asking price alone does not.

Note the condition and features of comparable properties as well as the price. A property that sold for more than the one you are looking at may have had a significantly better kitchen, a larger garden, or a more recent roof. The differences matter and inform how your offer should sit relative to what comparables show.

Understanding the local market at the time of your offer also matters. In a market where well-priced properties are finding buyers quickly and few reductions are being made, a well-pitched offer close to the asking price is more likely to succeed than one that attempts a significant discount. In a market where properties have sat for several weeks and asking prices have been reduced, there is often more room to move.

Present your position clearly and credibly

The number is only part of what the seller considers. The other part is confidence in the buyer’s ability to proceed. An offer from a buyer who has a mortgage in principle in place, has confirmed their deposit is ready, has a solicitor identified, and is in a strong chain position, or has no chain at all, is materially more attractive than an identical number from a buyer whose financial position is unverified and whose timeline is vague.

When you make an offer, communicate your position alongside it. State whether you are a cash buyer or have mortgage financing in place, confirm whether you have a property to sell and if so where in the process that sale is, and make clear approximately how quickly you could proceed if the offer were accepted. Sellers who have already accepted an offer that subsequently fell through are particularly sensitive to the credibility of a buyer’s position.

Where you are using a mortgage, having a Decision in Principle from a lender provides written evidence of the amount a lender has indicated it may be prepared to lend, based on your initial assessment. This is not a guarantee of a mortgage offer, but it demonstrates that you have been through an initial check and are not making an offer on a property you cannot actually finance.

How to pitch the number

There is no universal rule for how much to offer relative to the asking price, because the right figure depends entirely on the specific property, its condition, and current market conditions. What is consistent across markets is that the first offer is often not the final one, and leaving room to move marginally upward if needed gives a negotiation somewhere to go.

If a survey is going to happen before exchange, there may be an opportunity to renegotiate after it if significant defects are identified. Some buyers make a near-asking-price offer to secure the property and then use the survey findings to negotiate a reduction. Others prefer to build known defects into the initial offer. Either approach can work, but it is worth being clear in your own mind which route you intend to take before the offer is made.

Round numbers are not necessary and occasionally work against you. An offer of £299,000 on an asking price of £315,000 may land differently to £297,500, simply because the specificity of the second figure suggests a buyer who has done the arithmetic rather than made a round estimate.

If the offer is declined or countered

A declined offer is a conversation starting point, not a rejection of you as a buyer. Ask, through the agent, what the seller’s position is and what figure would be acceptable to them. This information shapes your next move. If the seller counters with a figure you are not prepared to meet, be straightforward about your ceiling. Sellers who understand a buyer’s maximum are better placed to make a decision than those left guessing.

Agents are legally obliged to pass on all offers to the seller. If you have reason to believe an offer has not been communicated, you can ask the agent to confirm in writing that it has been.

Talk to our team about buying your next home



Bookmarking: