Rent increase challenges are moving to the Valuation Office: What landlords should know

Rent increase challenges are moving to the Valuation Office: What landlords should know

The Renters’ Rights Act 2025, which came into force on 1 May 2026 in England, changed not only the grounds on which landlords can seek possession, but also the framework through which rent increases are set, challenged, and determined. One of the less widely understood areas concerns what happens when a tenant disputes a rent increase and, specifically, the role that the Valuation Office Agency is set to play in that process in the future. For landlords setting rents in 2026 and beyond, understanding both how the current challenge mechanism works and what is changing is as important as understanding the notice requirements themselves.

How rent increases work under the new rules

Under the Renters’ Rights Act, the fixed-term tenancy has been replaced for new and existing tenancies with a periodic tenancy structure. With fixed terms gone, the mechanism for increasing rent is now standardised across all tenancies in the private rented sector. Landlords must use a Section 13 notice, on the prescribed Form 4A, to propose a rent increase, giving the tenant at least two months’ written notice. The increase can only be applied once in any twelve-month period, regardless of what any previous tenancy agreement may have said about more frequent reviews.

A landlord cannot simply include a rent review clause in a tenancy agreement and use it to increase rent mid-tenancy. All increases must follow the Section 13 process. The notice must state the new proposed rent and the date from which it is to apply, and that date must be no earlier than the minimum notice period has expired.

What happens when a tenant challenges

If a tenant believes the proposed increase is above the market rent for their property, they have the right to refer the matter for determination before the new rent takes effect. Currently, rent challenge applications go to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), where a panel assesses what the open market rent for the property should be and determines accordingly.

The tribunal operates within defined parameters. It cannot set a rent higher than the landlord originally proposed. The tenant continues to pay the existing rent until the tribunal reaches its decision. The new rent determined by the tribunal usually takes effect from the date of the decision. Where payment of the new rent would cause the tenant hardship, the tribunal has the power to delay the increase by up to two months.

What is changing

The government announced on 9 September 2026 that responsibility for assessing rent increase challenges will move from the First-tier Tribunal to the Valuation Office Agency. No start date has been confirmed and legislation is still required to bring the change into effect. The details of the VOA procedure, the evidence it will accept, and the appeal route have not yet been published.

Landlords should monitor official guidance from HMRC and the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government for confirmation of when and how the new process will operate. Until that guidance is confirmed and in force, the First-tier Tribunal remains the route for all challenges.

Implications for how landlords approach rent increases

The existence of an independent challenge mechanism, whether through the tribunal now or the VOA in due course, changes the calculus around rent-setting in a practical way. A landlord who proposes a rent increase that is clearly grounded in local market evidence is in a defensible position regardless of whether a challenge is raised. A landlord who proposes an increase without that grounding risks having a correction applied.

Keeping records of comparable rental evidence at the point of issuing a Section 13 notice is a straightforward precaution. Rightmove and Zoopla both provide current rental listings by area and postcode, though these show asking rents rather than the rents properties have actually achieved. For the most reliable evidence of what similar homes are currently let for, a local letting agent with live knowledge of the market is the better source.

It is also worth noting the timing implications. If a tenant raises a challenge before the proposed increase date, the existing rent continues to be paid until a determination is made. The increase does not take effect simply because the notice period has passed. Landlords should factor this into their planning where rent increases are part of their income projections for a specific period.

The broader context

The challenge mechanism, in its current form and in its proposed future form, is designed to give both landlords and tenants a clear, formal route for resolving disagreements about rent. For landlords who set rents in line with what comparable properties are actually achieving in their local market, and who follow the Section 13 process correctly, the framework is straightforward to work within. The key is ensuring that any proposed increase is grounded in evidence from the outset.

Questions about rent reviews and tenancy management? Talk to our lettings team



Bookmarking: